Showing posts with label teaching tips. Show all posts
Showing posts with label teaching tips. Show all posts

Saturday, January 19, 2019

An English teacher argument for authentic audiences








Photo credit: Official White House photo by Pete Souza


Here is a post from a language arts teacher that never mentions journalism or student media, but which makes a compelling argument for strong media programs

Why Revise? Because You Have an Authentic Audience
Motivate students to revise their writing through self-publishing fiction, creating podcasts and YouTube videos, writing blogs, corresponding with others, and anything else for an authentic audience.

By Dylan Fenton / May 23, 2016

Whenever I start talking about the importance of revising our writing with my classes, I show them this photograph: an over-the-shoulder shot of Barack Obama holding a copy of his Inaugural Address from 2013. It's a printed page covered with his handwritten edits. Words are crossed out, arrows go every which way, and there are notes everywhere.

My point in showing this to students has always been: "Look how important revision is -- even the President of the United States takes the time to work on writing revision!" However, I used to overlook one key question when discussing the photograph with students: "Why did Mr. Obama care enough to revise his speech so much?"

Undoubtedly, the answer is that millions of people around the world would be listening to the speech, and thus he wanted his writing to be clear, precise, and flawless.

It should come as no surprise, then, that students care more about writing, revising, editing, proofreading, and perfecting their compositions when given a real-world audience. It's not just something that they've written for practice or a grade. It's a real piece of writing that will be read by real people in the real world.

Here are five successful writing strategies that I've used in my classroom to give students authentic audiences and motivate them to revise with gusto:

1. Self-Publishing Fiction
The world of self-publishing is more than just fan fiction and esoteric sci-fi. There are whole communities out there of budding writers sharing stories, giving each other feedback, and practicing the art of writing. Whatever kind of creative writing you do with your students, they can self-publish and connect with readers all over the world. Two of my favorite sites for students to self-publish are Wattpad and figment.

2. Recording Podcasts
This one comes with the added bonus that it forces students to read their writing aloud, which alerts them to all kinds of writing issues that would otherwise go unnoticed when reading silently. They can create podcasts about anything, but I've had students base them on National Public Radio's This I Believe series. Giving students the opportunity to literally voice their opinions is powerful stuff. Getting to share those opinions is even more powerful. PodBean is a great place for students to upload and share their podcasts with the world.

3. Blogging
As a blogger myself, I clearly value the power of writing short pieces concerning things that I'm passionate about. And guess what? So do students! They can create blogs about anything that interests them -- video games, sports, fashion, anything they choose. Not only will this passion-based writing energize them, but their words will also reach an audience that cares about the same things. I teach at a Google Apps for Education school, so having students create a public blog through Blogger is super easy, but edublogs, which is Wordpress' site targeted toward teachers and students, is also free.

4. Writing Correspondence
Learning to write letters, email, and other correspondence is an important skill in and of itself, but actually sending the correspondence to real people takes the lesson to a whole new level. I've had students write to prisoners of conscience around the world, with much success, as part of Amnesty International's Write for Rights campaign. However, students can also write to any public persona, such as a letter to their state governor about an issue facing their community, or an email to the author of a book they're reading. You could also go the old tried-and-true route of getting your students pen pals. Whatever you choose, the real power of this practice comes when students receive return correspondence. You can almost see their faces light up when they realize that their writing is deserving of a real-world response.

5. Making Videos for YouTube
The beauty of YouTube is that anyone can upload anything they want and instantly have an audience of millions. I've had students produce short, creative films based on books they were reading, but they can also create scripted how-to videos, screencasts, or interviews. This one is also great for giving students a chance to become amateur video editors and filmmakers -- not a bad bonus!

The Bigger Audience
Let’s face it. Most of us middle- or high-school teachers are only one of about eight that our students will have during the course of a year. We might build great relationships with them and they might respect our opinion, but for most of them, they have a limit to how much they care about our assessment of their work. And can we blame them for this? Of course not. After countless assignments throughout the school year, the motivation for students to really care about impressing teachers with their writing must be pretty difficult to muster by the time, say, April rolls around.

For conventional writing assignments, students are usually trying to meet the expectations of one person -- the teacher who assigned it. However, with an authentic audience, students are driven by the knowledge that their writing will leave the school, go out into the world, and be judged not for their ability to respond to an assignment, but for their ability to reach other people through their writing.

Do you give your students authentic writing assignments? Does it motivate them? 

Monday, November 12, 2018

We are at our best when we give away what we know

​On the generosity of spirit that lies at the heart of teaching:​​

From ​today's ​Seth Godin blog post – Nov. 12, 2019
The magnetic generosity of the network effect
​If you share a pizza with a large crowd, no one will be very satisfied.

But if you share an idea with a group, it creates cultural impact and becomes more valuable as it spreads, not less.

Most of the time, we adopt the scarcity model of pizza. “I don’t have that much, and if I share it with you, I won’t have any left…”

But in fact, the useful parts of our life are better characterized as, “If I share it with you, we’ll both have it.”

An idea shared is more powerful than one that’s hidden. A technology standard outperforms a proprietary one. A community is stronger than divided individuals ever could be.

When you give away your work by building the network, you’re not giving it away at all.

You’re building trust, authority and a positive cycle of better.

​
And then I remembered this wisdom from Annie Dillard, an incredible writer we may not quote from all that much these days...​ Sadly, Annie passed away in September of 2026.

An excerpt from Annie Dillard’s The Writing Life, published in 1989
Push it. Examine all things intensely and relentle​​ssly. Probe and search each object in a piece of art. Do not leave it, do not course over it, as if it were understood, but instead follow it down until you see it in the mystery of its own specificity and strength. Giacommetti*’s drawings and paintings show his bewilderment and persistence. If he had not acknowledged his bewilderment, he would not have persisted. A twentieth-century master of drawing, Rico Lebrun, taught that “the draftsman must aggress; only by persistent assault will the live image capitulate and give up its secret to an unrelenting line.” Who but an artist fierce to know – not fierce to seem to know – would suppose that a live image possessed a secret? The artist is willing to give all his or her strength and life to probing with blunt instruments those same secrets no one can describe in any way but with those instruments’ faint tracks.

Admire the world for never ending on you – as you would admire an opponent, without taking your eyes from him, or walking away.

One of the few things I know about writing is this: spend it all, shoot it, play it, lose it, all, right away, every time. Do not hoard what seems good for a later place in the book, or for another book; give it, give it all, give it now. The impulse to save something good for a better place is the signal to spend it now. Something more will arise for later, something better. These things fill from behind, from beneath, like well water. Similarly, the impulse to keep to yourself what you have learned is not only shameful, it is destructive. Anything you do not give freely and abundantly becomes lost to you. You open your safe and find ashes.

After Michelangelo died, someone found in his studio a piece of paper on which he had written a note to his apprentice, in the handwriting of his old age: “Draw, Antonio, draw, Antonio, draw and do not waste time.”

* Alberto Giacommetti (1901-1966) was a Swiss surrealist painter and sculptor, known for his innovative perception and work.

​Thanks for your willingness to give away what you know to so many. Thanks for sharing your passion for the truth and for student voices.


Friday, May 25, 2018

A modest proposal about yearbook group pictures

I would just like to suggest that group photos, generically, may be more trouble than they are worth. They are rarely accurate (some kids are missing and some sneak in, if you are not careful), they are static (and we already have static portraits of every individual elsewhere), and they often end up running so small that you can measure face size in pixels (rather than the once-hallowed rule that faces should run the size of a dime).

What's wrong with an accurate list of club members, accompanied by actual accomplishments and projects, fleshed out by excellent photography and some behind-the-scenes anecdotes?

Every veteran yearbook adviser I know has at least a few stories about group photo day weirdness. I do too. But after an editor of mine simply dropped group photos (in favor of expanded actual coverage)... no more disaster stories. Plenty of other disasters, of course, but they don't involve group photos.

We should start media education early


My wife and I finished a 9-week fifth-grade newspaper after-school course after our fifth-grade granddaughter asked us (and after she marched into her principal's office and demanded such a course). We met once a week, for an hour, and produced three 8-page letter-sized issues, printed at Staples. 

What I learned from teaching fifth graders: 
  • they are a tough crowd, with all sorts of diversity in maturity, experience, and physical size
  • they are smart, engaged and funny (duh!)
  • they can understand and begin actually doing journalism, and I taught them basically the very same skills I would teach ninth graders, or college freshmen, for that matter. 

So here's the secret to ensuring the future of student media: start kids thinking like journalists at a young age.

BTW, our third-grade granddaughter joined the staff, offering to do a quick story when someone else dropped the ball. Her writing voice and observations were as good as or better than many of the fifth graders. She ended up doing all the same exercises and assignments.

What if every elementary school in America began teaching journalism (in all sorts of forms, with all sorts of media) in third grade? The old Newspaper In Education programs had it right. They just didn't go far enough.

Contests: How to enter and why they are important


My approach to such contests in advising 30 yearbooks was to simply think of contests as one more thing to schedule. It took me some time to figure this out, but eventually, I kept a folder in which I would save copies of what I considered my students' best work as the year progressed. When March or April came along I did not have to browse through the entire book's PDFs (and I did the same with newspaper), but already had sifted through much of the material. 

It takes very little time these days to log on to contest sites and upload PDFs and enter a few other pieces of information. The time-consuming part is having to switch gears and sort through student work, all while trying to wrap up the book or prepare that final unit or get a daughter to her soccer practice.

I learned later that what I was doing was essentially conducting a formative assessment (rather than the traditional summative assessment after publication that yearbooks usually entail). If I found that I was not seeing much quality arising out of the first deadline or so, that helped me focus my teaching on helping students "up their game" a bit. This probably sounds quite elementary to you, and it does to me as I write it. But I valued the excitement and pride of being able to share awards with students at the end of the year so much that I never regretted those few hours spent along the way collecting good work. Most years I even gave my own informal awards for best writing in Deadline 2, or best spread from Deadline 3. Those in-class ceremonies were a good excuse for cake.

For much of my advising career, we had to literally cut up books to enter in contests. At one point I was ordering 6 extra books that would eventually be cut apart with Xacto knives and attached to paper entry forms. So much for the "good ol' days." PDFs are so much easier.

Some advisers believe strongly in students having the responsibility for all contests, but I never had students choose entries. I did it based on my experience, trying to consider our work from a stranger's perspective. I have been a judge for a very long time and I know what judges tend to look for and reward. This is one reason I urge advisers to consider judging and never to think they "just don't have the experience." Judging can be an adviser's most important professional practice.

I provided plenty of "go out of my way to praise" support for students who needed it, usually in long conversations, but  I never entered a student's work to make that student feel good. I never told a student I had entered her in a contest. I only announced winners, so I never had to spend much time commiserating with students about why they did NOT win. I got to spend my time on celebrating. I was always clear with students that awards are a bonus, and often wildly inconsistent from judge to judge. 

Yearbook is such a thankless job, for the adviser and the students. The school community will never comprehend how much work even a mediocre book is. And a terrific book is just taken in stride. After all, your readers don't normally read other schools' yearbooks so they can't compare. All those award certificates can and should become part of the conversation you might have with your principal about your program and maybe about your teaching assignment. 

Critiques have the same purpose: to confirm the adviser and staff's feelings about the effectiveness of their work all year. As with athletic success, publication awards can add to a school's culture.


Tuesday, March 18, 2014

Media classes pioneered 'flipped classrooms'

Something I first posted on my LinkedIn profile, as an experiment.
At all levels of education one of the current hot topics is the flipped classroom. This interest grows out of the increasingly accessible technology most students have in their pocket or purse, I would imagine. But the more I read about this idea, the more I think "everything old is new again."
Student media classes have functioned using the "flipped" model for many years. Class time is normally devoted to "doing": brainstorming, developing coverage lines, editing, writing (if computers are available), designing, adjusting photographs, etc.
Much of the education for media classes takes place online or in professional newspapers, magazines and websites... with students reading and evaluating. There is so much material available online that a student media adviser can best be defined as a curator. The job of the adviser is to sort through the volumes of materials and recommend the best to students.
The reporting (whether verbal or visual) in student media is done primarily outside class. After all, the news isn't happening inside the media class. It's out in the school, or in the community, on athletic fields and in auditoriums. Reporters, by definition, need to "get out there" and report.
A smoothly functioning student media class becomes a place to bring all the reading and planning and thinking and reporting together, with the goal of sharing information with the community. One student may ultimately publish news in the school newsmagazine, the yearbook, the website, social media, and video broadcast.
The teacher/adviser spends her time consulting, prodding, suggesting, praising and questioning. A media adviser in this sort of situation rarely spends time developing structured lesson plans or writing tests. The information and other help student journalists need is always "just in time." And the tests? We would call that publishing.

Monday, January 3, 2011

Teaching interviewing: a fundamental skill

From Brian Wilson, of Michigan, on the JEA listserv on Jan. 3:
I use a press-conference format as a way to teach caption writing, too. I ask my photo editor to find a variety of strong action photos and then I invite the subjects of those photos to class. I have the staffers fire off questions, press-conference style, based on what's happening in the photo. They eventually have to write a four-part caption (kicker, photo explanation, background, quote) for each of the photos. We share them in class.

This started because I realized that, in general, my staffers weren't asking very good questions of their interview subjects on their own. When they hear others ask them, they start to figure out the approach. I'm always amazed at the depth of information that comes up when we do this.

Anyway, if you're looking for a good place to start press-conferencing, maybe just look for some good photos.

And that got me thinking, so I replied with this:
I love Brian's approach, combining interviewing skills with finding news pegs and incorporating personality-revealing quotes. And it occurs to me that the photo doesn't have to be all that amazing for this to work.

I am thinking of Jim Richardson (a brilliant keynoter during the recent Kansas City convention) and his now out-of-print book "High School USA," published in 1979. Many of the amazing captions that accompanied the insightful (but often mundane) photographs he took of a small Kansas high school over a year are simply the transcribed and edited comments of people pictured. I treasure my copy of the book, and recommend searching for it online. I found 13 copies from various sellers at http://tinyurl.com/bfkx2ol

And that reminds me of a feature that used to run in the New York Times Magazine, called "What Were They Thinking?" (I regret that I no longer have samples of this feature -- perhaps Bob Greenman can point us to the correct archives...) The concept was simple: run a seemingly run-of-the-mill news photograph, and simply interview someone in the photo who could provide context and related information about that news. It was analagous to visting your grandparents' home and hearing extensive anecdotes about a posed photo circa 1912. Suddenly the photo pulsed with life, and real people emerged from the grim, stiff faces.

I have no problems with the 3-4 sentence extended caption, but wonder if readers might be very well-served by simply adding a knowledgable "voice" -- lightly filtered -- to our photographs.

So, Brian, thanks for reminding us that great caption writing is almost always the result of great interviewing.

Happy New Year!