Showing posts with label philosophy. Show all posts
Showing posts with label philosophy. Show all posts

Saturday, January 19, 2019

An English teacher argument for authentic audiences








Photo credit: Official White House photo by Pete Souza


Here is a post from a language arts teacher that never mentions journalism or student media, but which makes a compelling argument for strong media programs

Why Revise? Because You Have an Authentic Audience
Motivate students to revise their writing through self-publishing fiction, creating podcasts and YouTube videos, writing blogs, corresponding with others, and anything else for an authentic audience.

By Dylan Fenton / May 23, 2016

Whenever I start talking about the importance of revising our writing with my classes, I show them this photograph: an over-the-shoulder shot of Barack Obama holding a copy of his Inaugural Address from 2013. It's a printed page covered with his handwritten edits. Words are crossed out, arrows go every which way, and there are notes everywhere.

My point in showing this to students has always been: "Look how important revision is -- even the President of the United States takes the time to work on writing revision!" However, I used to overlook one key question when discussing the photograph with students: "Why did Mr. Obama care enough to revise his speech so much?"

Undoubtedly, the answer is that millions of people around the world would be listening to the speech, and thus he wanted his writing to be clear, precise, and flawless.

It should come as no surprise, then, that students care more about writing, revising, editing, proofreading, and perfecting their compositions when given a real-world audience. It's not just something that they've written for practice or a grade. It's a real piece of writing that will be read by real people in the real world.

Here are five successful writing strategies that I've used in my classroom to give students authentic audiences and motivate them to revise with gusto:

1. Self-Publishing Fiction
The world of self-publishing is more than just fan fiction and esoteric sci-fi. There are whole communities out there of budding writers sharing stories, giving each other feedback, and practicing the art of writing. Whatever kind of creative writing you do with your students, they can self-publish and connect with readers all over the world. Two of my favorite sites for students to self-publish are Wattpad and figment.

2. Recording Podcasts
This one comes with the added bonus that it forces students to read their writing aloud, which alerts them to all kinds of writing issues that would otherwise go unnoticed when reading silently. They can create podcasts about anything, but I've had students base them on National Public Radio's This I Believe series. Giving students the opportunity to literally voice their opinions is powerful stuff. Getting to share those opinions is even more powerful. PodBean is a great place for students to upload and share their podcasts with the world.

3. Blogging
As a blogger myself, I clearly value the power of writing short pieces concerning things that I'm passionate about. And guess what? So do students! They can create blogs about anything that interests them -- video games, sports, fashion, anything they choose. Not only will this passion-based writing energize them, but their words will also reach an audience that cares about the same things. I teach at a Google Apps for Education school, so having students create a public blog through Blogger is super easy, but edublogs, which is Wordpress' site targeted toward teachers and students, is also free.

4. Writing Correspondence
Learning to write letters, email, and other correspondence is an important skill in and of itself, but actually sending the correspondence to real people takes the lesson to a whole new level. I've had students write to prisoners of conscience around the world, with much success, as part of Amnesty International's Write for Rights campaign. However, students can also write to any public persona, such as a letter to their state governor about an issue facing their community, or an email to the author of a book they're reading. You could also go the old tried-and-true route of getting your students pen pals. Whatever you choose, the real power of this practice comes when students receive return correspondence. You can almost see their faces light up when they realize that their writing is deserving of a real-world response.

5. Making Videos for YouTube
The beauty of YouTube is that anyone can upload anything they want and instantly have an audience of millions. I've had students produce short, creative films based on books they were reading, but they can also create scripted how-to videos, screencasts, or interviews. This one is also great for giving students a chance to become amateur video editors and filmmakers -- not a bad bonus!

The Bigger Audience
Let’s face it. Most of us middle- or high-school teachers are only one of about eight that our students will have during the course of a year. We might build great relationships with them and they might respect our opinion, but for most of them, they have a limit to how much they care about our assessment of their work. And can we blame them for this? Of course not. After countless assignments throughout the school year, the motivation for students to really care about impressing teachers with their writing must be pretty difficult to muster by the time, say, April rolls around.

For conventional writing assignments, students are usually trying to meet the expectations of one person -- the teacher who assigned it. However, with an authentic audience, students are driven by the knowledge that their writing will leave the school, go out into the world, and be judged not for their ability to respond to an assignment, but for their ability to reach other people through their writing.

Do you give your students authentic writing assignments? Does it motivate them? 

Monday, November 12, 2018

We are at our best when we give away what we know

​On the generosity of spirit that lies at the heart of teaching:​​

From ​today's ​Seth Godin blog post – Nov. 12, 2019
The magnetic generosity of the network effect
​If you share a pizza with a large crowd, no one will be very satisfied.

But if you share an idea with a group, it creates cultural impact and becomes more valuable as it spreads, not less.

Most of the time, we adopt the scarcity model of pizza. “I don’t have that much, and if I share it with you, I won’t have any left…”

But in fact, the useful parts of our life are better characterized as, “If I share it with you, we’ll both have it.”

An idea shared is more powerful than one that’s hidden. A technology standard outperforms a proprietary one. A community is stronger than divided individuals ever could be.

When you give away your work by building the network, you’re not giving it away at all.

You’re building trust, authority and a positive cycle of better.

​
And then I remembered this wisdom from Annie Dillard, an incredible writer we may not quote from all that much these days...​ Sadly, Annie passed away in September of 2026.

An excerpt from Annie Dillard’s The Writing Life, published in 1989
Push it. Examine all things intensely and relentle​​ssly. Probe and search each object in a piece of art. Do not leave it, do not course over it, as if it were understood, but instead follow it down until you see it in the mystery of its own specificity and strength. Giacommetti*’s drawings and paintings show his bewilderment and persistence. If he had not acknowledged his bewilderment, he would not have persisted. A twentieth-century master of drawing, Rico Lebrun, taught that “the draftsman must aggress; only by persistent assault will the live image capitulate and give up its secret to an unrelenting line.” Who but an artist fierce to know – not fierce to seem to know – would suppose that a live image possessed a secret? The artist is willing to give all his or her strength and life to probing with blunt instruments those same secrets no one can describe in any way but with those instruments’ faint tracks.

Admire the world for never ending on you – as you would admire an opponent, without taking your eyes from him, or walking away.

One of the few things I know about writing is this: spend it all, shoot it, play it, lose it, all, right away, every time. Do not hoard what seems good for a later place in the book, or for another book; give it, give it all, give it now. The impulse to save something good for a better place is the signal to spend it now. Something more will arise for later, something better. These things fill from behind, from beneath, like well water. Similarly, the impulse to keep to yourself what you have learned is not only shameful, it is destructive. Anything you do not give freely and abundantly becomes lost to you. You open your safe and find ashes.

After Michelangelo died, someone found in his studio a piece of paper on which he had written a note to his apprentice, in the handwriting of his old age: “Draw, Antonio, draw, Antonio, draw and do not waste time.”

* Alberto Giacommetti (1901-1966) was a Swiss surrealist painter and sculptor, known for his innovative perception and work.

​Thanks for your willingness to give away what you know to so many. Thanks for sharing your passion for the truth and for student voices.


Friday, May 25, 2018

Do we need to use focus groups to create better yearbooks?

We should listen to our customers, and even more closely to our non-customers.

But focus groups are unlikely to provide anything useful for you and your staffs. As Steve Jobs once said, "“It's really hard to design products by focus groups. A lot of times, people don't know what they want until you show it to them.”

What I love most about yearbooks are the SURPRISES I encounter as I turn the pages. Who wants a yearbook (or a newsmagazine, or a broadcast) that simply gives us what we expected (or asked for in a focus group)? I see books, spreads, writing, visuals all the time that I never saw coming. I didn't know I would be delighted until I was, well, delighted. I could say the same about numerous movies, TV shows, etc.

Focus groups can be great for the ones leading the group, receiving the feedback they wanted all along. Such groups certainly check a management box such as "reaches out to customers and seeks input from them," but I have never seen random comments from students produce an "aha!" insight that leads to a future book that sells like hotcakes.

If you ask most students, they will opt for MORE photos and fewer captions... more photos of THEM, and more pages in the book, all at a lower cost. Sounds like promises about health care.

Yearbooks are somewhat immune to normal market forces, of course, since most students (and parents) buy them as a matter of course (it's tradition... it's history... our family has always done this...). In fact, the very heart of the yearbook business model is to sell books long before they are printed, or even fully reported. In a sense, LAST year's volume sells this year's. Yes, we count on selling some books after delivery, but charge a hefty penalty since we have to guess at those numbers (and may get stuck with lots of extra books if we guess wrong).

Think of how rare it is that we buy stuff sight unseen, mostly on faith. But that's what we ask yearbook customers to do, year after year.

The reasons students DO NOT buy yearbooks are legion, but likely culprits include raw cost, the potential buyer not feeling part of the larger school community (why buy a history of something I didn't much like?), clunky ordering processes, and more. But the quality of the book is rarely the key to sales success.

After all, would some kid at a school with a mediocre book trade for an amazing book from a school down the road? I would argue that the culture of the school is the key predictor of yearbook sales and that culture has lots of moving parts.

Maybe it's the school administration that needs to develop focus groups!

There are amazing yearbooks being distributed this month to a small percentage of the student body, and there are some pedestrian yearbooks with market penetrations north of 90 percent. In other words, there is something other than quality at work in sales. I'm not arguing that quality doesn't matter (it certainly does to the adviser and staff), just that it doesn't guarantee popularity.

No one asked, but my advice is to build a yearbook staff that is more reflective of the wider school community. That diverse staff can act as a running focus group that produces what the market wants.

How much time can we expect our readers to give us?


I had an "ah ha!" moment some years ago when I learned that the average American reads about 200 words per minute (sometimes called ART, or Average Reading Time).

My students and I began discussing coverage in terms that focused more on our readers (and less on page design), with the most fundamental question being: how much time will a kid be able to spend on any particular article? After all, few schools stop everything to allow students to read the latest issue of the printed paper, and online pieces face stiff competition from all the wonders of the Internet. No one kid will likely have time to read everything in a particular issue, nor even want to.

We once did a little survey that revealed that very few students spent more than 20 minutes reading the paper the day it came out, and most of that was wedged in during lunch or at the end of a class. (BTW: The Oregonian once ran a subscription campaign, claiming reading the paper was "the best 15 minutes of your day," so 20 minutes wasn't terrible.)

That was alarming, as we often were publishing 32 tabloid pages. We had various reasons for not reducing our page count, but the disconnect between the sheer volume of material we were publishing and our readers' available time meant we had to devote ourselves to providing "something for everyone, and making sure we design to attract readers browsing for something of interest." That same survey revealed that few students returned to the paper in the next 2-3 days to read more, which would be similar to "time shifting" your favorite TV show and watching later. Our readers were not "time shifting" their reading of the paper.

I suspect those survey results from 10 years ago resemble student media reading habits today.

Anyway, my students and I began talking about coverage in terms of "minutes readers might spend" on something they see. We became comfortable discussing whether a piece was a two-minute story (400 words) or a four-minute story (800 words). Sometimes we opted for 1,200 words or their equivalent. That's asking for six minutes, and concentrated minutes, at that.

Many times (most of the time?), the information warranted less than a minute, leading to more quick reads and alternatives to text.

You and your students might find it fun and instructive to play with the idea of how many minutes a reader might spend on the various stories in your next issue, and then work backward to assign words/space.

BTW, the above is 422 words, or a two-minute read, probably pushing most online readers beyond the time they can afford to devote to any one post. Sorry. It also is just over 2,300 keystrokes, so you could also think of this as a 17-tweet "storm."

Media literacy may pit journalism vs. ELA


There is so much famous literature with an unreliable narrator, but the very essence of journalism is that the narrator must be completely reliable (or at least be sharing "the best obtainable version of the truth," as Halderman puts it).

As far as danah boyd's views: they are about as bleak as possible. I must admit that truth is quite slippery, and it's not just Trump and his fantasies (endlessly repeated from all perspectives). It's an old problem, as I was reminded over Easter by Pilate's question: "What is truth?" He doesn't really get an answer.

For literature teachers, this search for truth is their bread and butter, and they prefer it in the form of "higher truths" found in fiction. They have a point -- we learn a lot from Shakespeare and Milton -- but what happens to a society in which most adults have not read a book in the past year, and in which reading fiction is not in their top 50 things to do... ever?

BTW: the preference for truth found in great fiction is one reason journalism education will never be fully embraced by NCTE and the vast majority of English teachers (my cynical view). Yes, there is a lot of talk about AP Lang and the need for students to "act like investigative reporters," but most English teachers, in their hearts, don't want to give up on fiction as the primary path to enlightenment.

I don't see how journalism education can continue if we are forced to abandon the core notion that there really IS some form of truth about events. Ironically, this may force journalism educators to have "faith" that truth exists, even in the face of "smart" people proclaiming that truth doesn't exist anymore (if it ever did). We need to hope that this belief system (that journalists are striving to report and reveal truth) will outlast the rising sense that the truth simply can't be ascertained.

As I get older, I begin to wonder if the REAL connection that would make a difference in schools is between media education and social studies. There is clearly some energy behind the "we need to educate citizens about the Constitution and laws and what responsibilities Americans have to their fellow citizens"... in short, in civics education. Those social studies teachers focused on history may be much more likely to care about the search for objective truth than English teachers. Social studies teachers are also more accepting of non-fiction writing as the ultimate in verbal expression. Great non-fiction (histories, for example) tends to read like great stories, focusing on characters and setting and conflict and resolution. As Matthew Arnold said, "Journalism is literature in a hurry." And history teachers are quite comfortable with history being revised as new facts are discovered.

I was one who advocated for stronger connections to our friends in Language Arts, but I now wonder if this was too simplistic, and too convenient, based on the fact that most journalism teachers were also in the English department. That was a structural convenience, ignoring the chasm between journalism and literature.

JEA and media educators have all the facts on their side when pointing out that thinking like a journalist is the best approach to teaching literacy, but the facts are not enough. Heck, when science teachers start seeing that facts are not enough (for individuals and for some communities), it's clear that less objective areas are in trouble.

One question that needs to be addressed (perhaps by smarter people than me): what factors are necessary for teachers trained as literature teachers (that would be all English majors) to bridge the chasm and embrace journalism as a valid (maybe the best) way to tell stories, to find truth, to become more human?

I was certainly a classically trained English major, but I didn't teach like one (after a while). Most advisers were not journalism majors. Few even had a journalism methods class. I sort of fell into advising, since it came with the gig, but what makes some teachers dig in and read about and study how journalism works, while most advisers drop out of the profession within a year or two?

What if our students just don't get the job done?


There was a recent JEA listserv thread about students not finishing a yearbook, and what to do about it. Beyond being angry, I have no handy answer, no cookbook recipe for this issue.

I will offer this: What is the worst that might happen if a yearbook were not published until several months later than scheduled? Would the history somehow be damaged? Would the truths be somehow less true? So please opt for completing the best book possible, rather than simply cutting your losses.

But the discussion brought up so many thoughts, which do not add up to a clear thesis but help explain the lack of an easy answer to the original problem. Here we go:

Yearbook is part of the curriculum (if students are offered a class), but it's also somehow "outside" the curriculum, providing THE history of the year. It is an artifact that is treated as a complete work of art, despite the fact that students were learning as the book was being created. Heaven forbid that spreads from the first deadline do not measure up to spreads from a later deadline!

Many yearbook advisers struggle with what to do about customers (students) who simply fail to pick up their copy of the book. Are we enabling their bad behavior by tracking them down and thrusting a book into their hands? Or should we honor their choice to waste some money (and leave us with a few boxes of rejected books)?

Yearbooks should be produced by students, but the pride, professionalism, and even job security of the adviser can't be separated from that student work.

When a football coach happens to be working with a mediocre group of athletes, the record of the team likely represents that mediocrity. No one would seriously consider having the coaching staff take the field, and thus improving the quality of the team.

On the other hand, a coach who never has a winning season... at some point, there will be a new coach.

Coaches usually have the option to cut certain players who are not up to the task, but many advisers don't have that option or get caught in a numbers game (where the course may be cut if a minimum number of students are not enrolled).

Sometimes students are simply dumped into a class, without much interest or motivation, and then live down to that... and are then marked with an "F"... well, that just seems punitive and maybe a little mean. Who is grading the counselors or administrators or the overall school environment that put those young people in such an untenable position? Imagine students being forced to play football, no matter their size or skill or interest.

But perhaps football is too important to mess with like that.

When we find ourselves surrounded by students to whom failure is not all that daunting... well, our community must have issues that go far beyond our class or our school.

Perhaps my "spinning" arises from the fact that I always thought the students and I were in this wacky thing together, and that makes it difficult to assign blame. We failed many, many times. But we didn't stop playing the game.

I feel sympathy for frustrated educators, feeling defeated at the end of a long year. But there is good news! We can do better next school year and getting better starts now.

Adviser health is worth thinking about


A real issue I see is advisers being defeated in their careers before they really can start, since we masochistically repeat over and over just how difficult the job is (and I have been saying this for years so I am part of the problem). You have to master not only all the intricacies of journalism but also of technology and design and social media and video and...

In other words: to be a great adviser you must be expert in everything, and it turns out that there are not many Aaron Manfulls and Jim Streisels out there. But is that fair?

I started a discussion with Colorado advisers during our annual winter professional development event, in which I asked them to forgive themselves for not being able to do it all.

I recommended becoming an expert in one thing (for me, it was writing, with print as the prime medium). Adviser "lifespan" has been brief and is getting briefer. All the pressure to "do it all" is either a) making that span even shorter, or b) producing loads of student work that gets lost in the chaos; or both.

Does anyone really believe that we can churn out young journalists who can be "expert" as writers, broadcasters, bloggers, designers, marketers, podcasters, and social media gurus? When you have to be great at everything, aren't we great at nothing? My quick take on media education is that we have forgotten the truth of "depth over breadth," and so we now see oceans of mediocre content coming from young people. And need I even bring up the same problem in the professional media?

Then came a recent JEA listserv discussion on the advisability (pretty good word for this, eh?) of taking on multiple publications and THAT got me thinking again about advisers needing to "forgive themselves" for not being expert in everything to do with student media.

My thinking on this can be traced to a 2011 blog post by Linda Holmes, host of "Pop Culture Happy Hour." It's worth reading and maybe sharing with students.

I continue to struggle for the right analogy here, but imagine being asked to be a high school teacher assigned a combined high-level science and English course ("It will really help in building the master schedule and there's an extra $500 in it for you," pleads the principal). It's not an exact comparison to advising yearbook AND video broadcast AND online, but a lot of advisers are trying to cram all those into one period per day.

I can see some hazy ways to proceed, but I would be inventing curriculum on the fly, spending many hours trying to get on top of the content, and trying to find a support community that could talk with me. I would face students each day who were talented in science and not so talented in analyzing literature, and vice versa. I would have to find some reasonable middle ground in terms of content and challenges for those students. Every day would be a bit frustrating, no matter how bright and dedicated those students were.

As several posters mentioned in the listserv discussion, there ARE times when teachers are forced to make extreme decisions due to enrollment pressure, scheduling pressure and more (e.g. in order to maintain ANY journalism at our school, we need to jam everyone into one class; or Spanish teachers jamming levels 3-5 into one class period in order to save the entire sequence). Depending on school size, it is still quite common for one person to advise all the media in a particular school, often with dedicated classes.

It CAN be done and done well, and some of the most inspiring, successful and honored advisers in the history of JEA (and many of them are advising RIGHT NOW) prove this daily. I thought I was a pretty decent adviser, though I never REALLY was able to fully grasp the Tao of Yearbook, despite advising 30 of them, and though I never found enough time or energy to REALLY do the very best I could do in, well, anything. I always had to compromise somewhere, and I only had to worry about newspaper and yearbook and various Language Arts classes. What a wimp!

Since 1975, the standards for being an "expert" student media adviser have expanded exponentially, and I now believe we are reaching some sort of tipping point, where advisers are overwhelmed and simply leaving teaching or advising, or are struggling to keep up on every trend and every opportunity, feeling increasingly stressed and stretched. Advising has always had a huge attrition rate, but it feels worse today.

I have started questioning whether the "new requirements" for college and professional journalists -- that they must be able to be "expert" at reporting, writing, podcasts, video, social media, web and print design, photography, and marketing/business -- are really going to produce better journalists. Maybe. Certainly, those who do the hiring would like to employ journalists who do it all, in expert fashion, for not much money.

Those publishers are not much different from school administrators looking for that one adviser who can do it all and do it well, are they?

I wonder if we have fallen into the trap of thinking that since a small percentage of our students will need ALL skills in order to land that plum gig with The Times (and I wonder if that is really true), that we as advisers must acquire/manage those skills as well.

Will some advisers, through their talent, drive, and energy, get it done? Yes, and you can meet most of them at national conventions.

But I have watched so many talented, passionate, and dedicated advisers leave our ranks over so many years. I'm not suggesting that we wave a white flag, essentially giving up the fight to provide the best education possible for our students (and, dare I say, for our country?).

I'm just wondering about our health. 

Wednesday, June 18, 2014

Would they miss us if we were gone?

Below is today's Seth Godin post, and this should be part of our summer reading. We perhaps worry a lot about numbers and likes and assorted SMART goals. Godin reminded me of why those stats never leave me very satisfied.

Tough to measure, but the real reason we became educators, is how we have developed student voices, insights and passions.


Just one guy's view here, but my impression is that student media nationally is becoming more and more generic (and that means, BTW, that the overall quality is pretty good... maybe better at some level than ever before).


I value a student press that produces media you can recognize immediately, even without a nameplate or logo. The take on the news is unique. The voices of the writers are localized and authentic (warts and all). Strong doses of passionate rhetoric, along with a clear sense of fun, and an idealism that makes an education veteran wince.


Godin asks the ultimate question in today's post: "Would people miss us if we were gone?" Now that's a sobering question for student journalists and advisers alike.


Summer is precisely the time to reflect on what we do and why we do it, and finding ways to synthesize ideas from varied sources (like Mr. Godin), seems worth an hour or two.

Seth's Blog - 6-18-2014
In search of meaningful

From the individual who needs to get her idea in front of the right people, to the New York Times, which faces a ticking clock to figure out the digital landscape, all of us are in the media business. There's a gold rush for attention going on, and, given how much the media likes to cover the media, we hear about winners and losers, those doing it right and wrong, and most of all, the template for what we ought to be doing if we want to succeed.
I fear that right now, many are laboring under Buzzfeed Envy.
Since 1989, when I first started doing online media, people have been transfixed by scale, by numbers, by rankings. "How many eyeballs, how big is the audience, what's the passalong, how many likes, friends, followers, how many hits?" 
You cannot win this game and I want to persuade you (and Dean Baquet at the Times) to stop trying.
1. Are you generic? Over the last few years, the Times has lost Lisa Belkin, Nate Silver, David Pogue and other big name writers, not to mention the opportunity to do more with Michael Lewis and the Freakonomics guys. Here's the thing: when you read what these singular voices create, you know where it came from, and you have an opinion about it. 
Buzzfeed doesn't focus on who is speaking, they focus on writing something clickable and shareable and urgent in the moment. Those that want to own a valuable 'brand' like the fact that it belongs to them, unlike the demanding star writer, who might leave at any time. The value all goes to the system, not to the individual contributor.
(Buzzfeed is well on its way to becoming a dominant media company. But the Times isn't Buzzfeed, and neither are you.)
The problem with generic is that it's easy go as well as easy come. The Onion just launched their own sharable silliness and to those that spread it, it doesn't matter at all if the person writing it works for one brand in the genre or the other one. Staying ahead and gaining scale gets more difficult, not less for those in this segment.
Kasey Casem is remembered precisely because he refused to become generic. When he left his show and started a new one, so many people followed him that he was able to buy back the original show and run both of them at the same time. We were connected to him, not the idea of a radio show.
2. Is it for the reader or the search engine? Here's an excerpt from how editors are deciding things at the Times now: "There was praise for headlines that had contained the right words ... to maximize online search results." 
The most important thing any individual or corporate media entity needs to learn is this: One subscriber is worth 1,000 surfers. Newspapers learned this a century ago. The Philadelphia Inquirer created one of the richest families in America on the basis of a focus on subscriptions. And Time magazine has turned into a nearly valueless relic because they forgot to focus on subscribers and pandered to the newsstand and to the listicle instead.
[A subscriber, by my definition, doesn't have to pay with money. Sometimes, it's sufficient to pay with attention.]
3. Would I miss it if it were gone? And here's the key question, the one that gets to the heart of meaningful. When we deliver meaningful content, it means we show up, invited, with words and images that matter. It means that we are trusted enough to be permitted to speak the first few words, and talented enough to keep the attention we've worked so hard to earn. Most of all, meaningful can't possibly work for everyone with a smart phone, for everyone in every potential audience, because there are so many ways to be seen as meaningful, so many different tribes of people thirsting for different kinds of connection.
Here's the key flaw in the bigger-is-better reasoning: It's entirely possible to become an important voice merely because everyone is listening. (Walter Cronkite, or the front page of Yahoo in 1999). When everyone is listening, anyone who wants to be part of everyone also has to listen. That's certainly why the most viral viral videos get so many views--the second half of their views are people who don't watch viral videos, but need to get clued in.
There are still some advertisers who want the biggest mass they can find, who will pay extra to reach more people who care less, but those advertisers are going to find someone bigger than you to advertise with.
It's no longer possible to become important to everyone, not in a reliable, scalable way, not in a way that connects us to people who will read ads or take action, not to people who aren't already clicking away to the next thing by the time they get to the second or third sentence.
But it is possible to become important to a very-small everyone, to a connected tribe that cares about this voice or that story or this particular point of view. It's still possible to become meaningful, meaningful if you don't get short-term greedy about any particular moment of mass, betting on the long run instead. And we need institutions that can reach many of these tribes, that can bind together focused audiences and useful content creators.
Newspapers used to work because they were local, delivered and urgent, with few competitors.
Today, all four components have changed dramatically. Craigslist and others have stolen a lot of the revenue that came from local, anyone with email can be delivered, and the news cycle has bypassed the daily rhythm of the newspaper. And few competitors has become infinity competitors.
The future of newspapers (and for anyone making content) is to act more like a magazine, like Fast Company and Wired and The New Yorker of fifteen years ago. The center, the urgent center, of a smaller everyone.
My advice to the Times starts with this: Every reporter (and probably every editor) ought to have a blog (or be part of a focused group blog), and post every single day. That's perhaps 600 blogs, every single day, each charged with finding a group of people who care enough about that voice and that topic to hear about it daily. If a reporter can't write cogently and passionately enough about his topic to gain a following, he probably needs to work somewhere else. And if the paper can organize to hire and train and reward people who can do work like this, if they can figure out how to get out of the 48-page paper mindset, if it can create stars and pockets of true connection, it's inconceivable to me that they won't be able to turn a profit.
Of course, one straightforward act isn't going to change the future of the Times, but it represents a symptom, a visible sign that the focus is changing from making an above-average (or even excellent) newspaper for the masses into creating circles of expertise, organizing tribes, building subscriptions based on attention and publishing outside of the finite world of paper... (And I firmly believe that this applies even more to individuals and smaller organizations than it does to legacy newspapers).
The future of media can't possibly only lie in random mass viral entertainments, generated with the aid of computers and aimed at the lowest-clicking denominator. For most organizations, that can't lead to useful ads, it doesn't lead to subscriptions, and most of all, it doesn't lead to impact. Entertaining the people who click on 50 things a day will get you numbers, but it won't make a difference.
If it's not worth subscribing to a particular voice or feature or idea, if it's not worth looking forward to and not worth trusting, I'm not sure it's worth writing, not if your goal is to become meaningful.
The three questions to ask, then, at every editorial meeting:
Who is this for?
Will we be able to reach them?
Is it meaningful?
And here's the rhetorical question I'd ask the publisher of every media company, from the sole practitioner to the Times: If you had the loyal attention of the powerful, connected, concerned and intelligent people in any given (valuable) tribe or sector, and you regularly showed up with anticipated, personal and relevant content for those people, could you make it into a business?

Tuesday, March 18, 2014

Is there potential peril when school newspapers go online only?

My gut tells me the answer is YES.

I can picture mornings at City High in Iowa City or at Rock Canyon HS in Highlands Ranch, when the school newsmagazine "hit the halls."

Hundreds of students, often just sitting in hallways, poring over the pages of the paper. Sometimes pointing something out to a neighbor. More often just immersed in a particular story.

It was a shared experience that simply can't be replicated by even the most sophisticated student media websites or social media. In a world increasingly lacking the sorts of shared experiences that communities thrive upon (hundreds of TV choices, DVRs, segmented news outlets online, etc.), there is something to be said for the somewhat old-fashioned printed newspaper.

I like the model of combining a strong print publication with strong journalism on a website and reaching readers through various social media. But perhaps that's just me being a bit afraid to commit to new technologies, to the new truth of students being "digital natives."

There is a lot of pressure on high schools to abandon the print publication (due to expense, mostly, but also due to people in power knowing just how much influence a shared experience can have, and seeing the benefit in more diffuse experiences). In schools large and small, urban and rural, the yearbook is the last print publication remaining.

So I worry. Then, for some reason, I come upon two online sources (yes, I understand the irony here) that support my angst.

The first is at http://tinyurl.com/o9yxp5s and it summarizes the results of a study on how Seattle and Denver losing a daily print newspaper lowered civic engagement in those communities. I have a daughter who works for the Seattle Times (the surviving print paper there), and a daughter who was an editor at the Rocky Mountain News when it was shuttered, so I was doubly engaged in this report. I was not surprised to find that the news for both cities was not good, at least in the short term.

The second item I came across was a Ted Talk, recommended by a speaker I heard who did a lunch talk for marketing professionals, which I attended almost accidentally. Well, it's a related Ted Talk to the one she recommended, but you know how things are on the web: one click lead to another...

Anyway, I checked out the video and found myself wondering how I had never run into this idea before, at least stated this way. Part of the speaker's premise was that we humans have a need, rooted in our very biology and brain structure, to connect with one another in person.

I made the leap to: if our communities get too big to have personal contact with everyone, perhaps at least reading the same text, sharing the same experience, might be the next best thing.

Bottom line: keep that newspaper, newsmagazine, magazine... whatever it is you call that printed publication that seems increasingly out of step with the rush of technology, the eye-popping videos on a phone or tablet.

That shared experience is worth keeping.

Tuesday, January 11, 2011

Provoking thought... our daily responsibility

My buddy Mark Newton passed on this link today, which is related to the Tucson shootings but focuses on one of the very bedrock principles of free expression. The writer's argument defending free speech, while challenging those who exercise free speech to stand by what they express, is an essential part of journalism education. We need to push our students to carefully consider their views before they publish, and then to stand strongly behind their considered views.

In class, we might discuss the difference between a rapidly constructed tweet and a reasoned blog entry. One is the equivalent of an off-the-cuff comment in the lunchroom, while the other is one of the treasured outcomes of true education. Which of those forms of expression are we more likely to stand behind when confronted with opposition? We need to share these sorts of opinion pieces with our students, not to pressure them to believe some point of view in particular, but to get them to value good writing and how it can be achieved. It is important, of course, to find balance in these examples, so you might add in this link to the discussion, which comments on the Tucson shootings and Sarah Palin but from a different direction.

The key question is always: "How did the writer use language to make her point?"

Saturday, June 21, 2008

Who owns the story?

There are a variety of ways to approach this question, but let me suggest this answer as a way to combine our interests as teachers as well as our interests as publishers/advisers:

A story belongs to the writer, for the most part. That is, although editors and advisers may read, respond to and suggest changes to a story, the actual rewriting/revising should be done by the writer. Could these revisions be accomplished more efficiently by an editor? Perhaps, but we all know that such efficiencies actually slow the learning for the writer. The best editors provide support, advice and attention, but avoid writing the stories themselves.

BUT... there does come a time when the ownership of a story shifts from the writer to the publication. At a certain point in the process (for instance, two days before the paper goes to press, or whatever seems workable) it seems counterproductive to simply let inferior material run, with the rationale that it will be very educational for the deficient reporter.

Our readers deserve better than that. They don't know or care about the total educational picture for a reporter. They want their news, and they want it right.

Occasionally I see a paper with a blank space, with a small explanatory bit of type saying that so-and-so failed to do her job. Sorry, but we can't bring you that story, or that photo. Ouch! It must feel pretty satisfying at a visceral level to publicly hang that kid out to dry, but I wonder if the paper itself isn't taking a worse hit.

And one more thought: The hardest thing you will ever do as an adviser is keep your hands off a story or design that you KNOW you could improve. After all, you are the journalism "coach," and if your team performs poorly, there certainly may be some reflection on you.

But coaches don't make tackles, or shoot 3-pointers during games. It's not a perfect analogy, but my point is that the paper belongs to the students, not the teachers, administration or general public. You can be as hands-on as you want during practice. You can map out a game plan. You can critique the game films. But when the ball is kicked off, you are stuck stewing on the sidelines, just like the football coach.

May your next issue have no dropped passes, no silly penalties and no lack of hustle!

Grading - art or science?

Ugh... grading.

You would make me try to write down what I do, wouldn't you?

Anyway, the analogy I begin with is that of the varsity football team. If a kid sticks with the team all year and is a senior, but hardly ever gets in the game, he still gets a varsity letter -- the same varsity letter that the star running back gets.

What the star running back gets beyond the letter is adulation, possible scholarships, etc.

What the not-so-talented or hard working kid gets is the chance to play on the Kickoff Return team (which is where I used to stick kids where they would do the least damage when I coached). But that kid was needed in practice, because we needed people to practice against. And perhaps he provided some comic relief. And perhaps it was enough for that kid just to be part of the team. Who knows?

Some football players are lazy and break training rules, yet still start and still are stars. Some football players work hard all the time, but just aren't very big, or very talented. Same with journalists.

But they all deserve a letter. It's a team, after all, and one of the chapters in my favorite leadership book "Management of the Absurd," is "People we think need changing turn out to be pretty good after all." In other words, looking back at groups we are part of, we find that it took all types to make up the whole, and it would have been a different group, a "lesser group, if we had changed them all into clones of ourselves.

So... pretty much everybody gets an A from me on newspaper or yearbook (sort of like a varsity letter). If they screw up, I occasionally drop them to a B or even lower. Oh my!

Grades are like praise for me: they don't really motivate people (as "Management of the Absurd" reminds us). They simply demonstrate my power. So I begin the semester saying, "Everybody gets an A, unless you mess up the rest of the staff so badly we can't fix it. Now let's talk about being a great newspaper/yearbook."

That is it.

Do I still get ticked at kids who screw around? Miss deadlines? Forget to run spell check? Interview only friends? Of course. But what makes me happy is a great team, and teams never work well when some team members get all the attention and acclaim from the coach.

Others give my "stars" their acclaim, in the form of individual and group awards from Quill and Scroll, or the Colorado High School Press Association, or any number of other organizations.

From me, they get constructive criticism, and an "A" if they even come close to doing what they are supposed to.

When an editor complains to me that some staffer is getting the same grade as she is, even though he is not doing quality work, I say, "Does that diminish your grade? If not, are you looking for justice? You may have to search a long time to find justice in this world. And don't you get to cover the plum assignments? Don't you get to control much of what goes into the paper? Don't others acknowledge your talent? What more do you want? Do you want me to beat the crap out of the lower performing people?"

Then we laugh.

To finish with my football analogy, I much prefer the pass-fail approach to grading (or A-F). If you skip enough practices and mess around enough, you get dismissed from the football team. Same with the newspaper or yearbook staff.

Screw up enough and you don't come back next term.

That's my grading philosophy, and I'm sticking with it.

Friday, June 20, 2008

Role of the Adviser

My preferred strategy is to think of myself as the journalism coach, and to allow myself the same involvement as, say, a football coach. Can you imagine members of a football team claiming that they are a student-run team? That they will decide everything? Look, I won't push the analogy so far as to say it's okay for me to call all the plays, but the coach analogy is worth thinking about.

Perhaps I'm just old-fashioned, but our editors are still in high school, right? It seems possible that they are not yet professional journalists, and that an experienced, caring and creative adviser might just have a few good ideas, practices and techniques to share.

Football coaches critique the play of the team (game films are exhaustively graded), and often changes are made in personnel and strategy based on those critiques. Football coaches are in charge of practice. So should advisers be heavily involved in training and planning.

There are many possible approaches to advising a publication, but the approach that some take in which the adviser practices a form of "benign neglect" -- rarely even speaking to the class (the editors do that), shrugging her shoulders when things go horribly wrong (claiming it's the students' publication, so what could I do?) -- seems to ignore what we all innately understand about education. To take their position to a perhaps illogical conclusion: there is no need for a trained adviser at all. Someone to unlock the door, perhaps? Or maybe the students want the keys, as well?

Advisers should inspire, should push, should suggest, should critique, should evaluate. They should get over being the "super editor" of the publication, correcting all grammar errors, etc. They should sometimes ignore some silliness or lack of sophistication. They should come to grips with the fact that the publication will not ever be perfect.

Deciding how you will balance your multiple roles will be key to your satisfaction as an adviser. How would you describe your adviser philosophy?